This is a Preprint and has not been peer reviewed. This is version 3 of this Preprint.
Downloads
Supplementary Files
Authors
Abstract
Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring inspired a wave of research on the impacts of organochlorine pesticides, followed by a subsequent wave of meta-analyses. These meta-analyses are now routinely used to inform policy decisions. However, the methodological quality of meta-analyses on organochlorine pesticides remains largely unknown. Here, our study systematically maps and evaluates the methodological quality of 105 meta-analyses synthesizing 3,911 primary studies. Concerningly, we find that 83.4% of the meta-analyses exhibit low methodological quality. Importantly, such meta-analyses are commonly cited in policy documents, suggesting poor quality meta-analyses are misinforming policies. We also found a paucity of meta-analyses on wildlife despite ample primary evidence. Furthermore, our bibliometric analysis shows a limited number of meta-analyses originating from the developing countries, where organochlorines are still used to combat vectors of fatal diseases. Finally, we quantified the positive impact of using reporting guidelines and we provide recommendations for readily implementable methodological improvements.
DOI
https://doi.org/10.32942/X2JS6S
Subjects
Physical Sciences and Mathematics
Keywords
agrochemical, meta-regression, Critical Appraisal, Bibliometrics
Dates
Published: 2024-04-16 13:24
Last Updated: 2024-04-16 17:26
Older Versions
License
Additional Metadata
Language:
English
Conflict of interest statement:
There is no conflict of interest to declare.
Data and Code Availability Statement:
For reproducibility and transparency, the code used to complete the systematic review map and bibliometric analysis is provided in a public GitHub repository: https://github.com/KyleMorrison99/organochlorineSRM_analysis.The R markdown file is also available via the following link: https://kylemorrison99.github.io/organochlorineSRM_analysis/.
There are no comments or no comments have been made public for this article.