Cetaceans of the Black and Azov Seas as Indicators of Habitat Quality via Stacked Species Distribution Models

Volodymyr Tytar, Leonid Fedorenko

Habitat degradation and biodiversity loss in the Black and Azov Seas necessitate improved tools for spatially explicit conservation planning. We employed stacked species distribution modelling (SSDM) to assess habitat quality for the three resident cetacean species—the common dolphin (Delphinus delphis ponticus), the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus ponticus), and the harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena relicta)—which serve as apex predators and indicators of ecosystem health. Occurrence data were compiled from the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF), and ensemble species distribution models (ESDMs) were constructed using nine algorithms within the SSDM framework, with eight environmental predictors extracted from Bio-ORACLE v3.0. Individual ESDMs demonstrated excellent predictive performance (AUC: 0.82–0.83; TSS: 0.65–0.67; prop.correct: 0.82–0.83). However, the initial continuous stacking method (pSSDM) yielded low community-level prediction success (0.36), prompting evaluation of three correction approaches. The Probability Ranking Rule (PRR) substantially improved performance (prediction.success = 0.459, sensitivity = 0.704, Jaccard = 0.465), effectively mitigating the overprediction bias inherent in stacked models. Species richness mapping identified multi-species hotspots along the southwestern Black Sea shelf, the Crimean coast, the Kerch Strait, and parts of the eastern coast, while the deep central basin exhibited the lowest richness. Variable importance ranking revealed bathymetry as the primary community-level driver (41.2%), followed by dissolved oxygen (13.8%), sea surface temperature (11.9%), and salinity (10.4%). Species-specific importance patterns confirmed ecological niche segregation, with common dolphins favouring deeper offshore waters and bottlenose dolphins and harbour porpoises associated with shallower shelf environments. The moderate richness observed in the highly productive northwestern shelf, despite high nutrient inputs, may reflect a combination of natural factors (elevated turbidity, reduced salinity) and anthropogenic pressures (fisheries bycatch, shipping, coastal development, and military activity) that limit species co-occurrence. Our findings demonstrate that PRR-corrected SSDM provides a robust framework for mapping cetacean habitat quality and identifying conservation priorities in the Black and Azov Seas, offering an evidence-based tool to inform ecosystem-based management in this ecologically unique and increasingly pressured marine region.